TL;DR: These are very good gloves and are much more durable than the other ones I bought. They are a little more expensive, so if durability isn't an issue, those others will suffice, but then, since those appear to be no different from the generic gloves available everywhere, you may be able to find cheaper ones with similar performance. However, if durability is important, while I can't say these are the best since I only tried the two, they are definitely significantly better.I bought a box of these and a box of Semperguard "Blue Nitrile Disposable Gloves Powder Free Textured 4 Mil Thickness Latex Free Food & Safety Glove (Large Box)" at the same time. I've used both several times, almost exclusively for light-duty tasks, mainly cleaning, and for that purpose both work fine, and since those are a bit cheaper they're really the better choice for that. These are also a tighter fit (snug, not tight), but I got them in medium whereas the others I got in large (I almost always get gloves of all types in large, and I wasn't sure which way to go for these; medium works but large probably would as well), so it's not a straight comparison. I generally prefer the snugness of these, but they're harder to take off because of it, so the others are my go to if I'm doing something where I want to be able to reuse them. If I'm doing something more detailed, the second-skin fit of these is nice. But again, that's largely due to the difference in ordered sizes. I only mention it in case it helps someone who's tried one pick a size in the other, and to basically say that for light-duty tasks, they work equally well to the point the fit is how I choose which to go with.That said, for heavier-duty tasks that are going to be rougher on the gloves, I would definitely recommend these. The other gloves are just your generic, cheap nitrile gloves you can get pretty much anywhere, whereas these have a more durable look and feel to them that's slight but instantly noticeable. I did some tests to compare the durability and the results were pretty much what I expected (I tried very hard to not be biased by the expectation while doing the tests and did what I could to keep them fair). The first thing I did was put a glove on each hand and repeatedly dragged my index (pointer) and middle fingers across a large rough stone, one hand next to the other. I also crossed my hands after a while to make sure each glove was exposed to both areas of the stone, in case one was a bit rougher than the other. It didn't take very long for a hole to develop on one finger of the other gloves. It took a while past that before a hole developed in the second finger and the first hole developed in these, both of which happened close to the same time. I went a bit longer after this then stopped. Even the second hold in the other glove was a bit larger than the first hole in these (again, they started at roughly the same time), so it seems not only are those more prone to tearing, but the tears worsen quicker as well. Then again, it's only a small difference, and a small sample size, so it's hard to be sure based on that.The second test I did was I inserted a tool into the ring finger of each glove (to simulate a finger, for safety vs using an actual finger) and used my Milwaukee "Dremel" to "grind" the finger with a 1" felt polishing wheel at a speed setting of 2.5/6, which is ~13,500rpm assuming the speed increases linearly. I had to lift up periodically to check the progress, but I did so briefly and tried to keep the frequency and duration of doing so similar for each glove. I also tried to keep the pressure the same. Not the most scientific of tests, but I'm satisfied with it. This glove lasted around 45-50 seconds before a tear developed, and I stopped at one minute. As you can see in the picture, that extra 10-15 seconds didn't do much to increase the size of the tear, as it's still quite small. The other glove, on the other hand, developed a tear within 15-20 seconds, and I stopped at 30 seconds, a whole half-minute less than this one. As you can see, it was basically demolished. And again, it seems that once a tear starts, it enlarges much more quickly.